HLL Lifecare Limited (A Government of India Enterprise)

Birth Control Methods: Compare Effectiveness, Side Effects and Cost

The most effective birth control methods are the implant, IUDs and sterilization, each over 99% effective. The shot is about 96% effective and the pill, patch and ring about 93% with typical use. Condoms are about 87% effective but are the only method that also helps prevent STIs. The right choice depends on your health and goals.

Key takeaways

  • The implant, IUDs and sterilization are over 99% effective.
  • The pill, patch and ring are about 93% effective with typical use.
  • Only condoms also protect against STIs.
  • You can get the pill without a prescription or by telehealth.
  • Most US private plans cover birth control with no copay under the ACA.
Birth control methods laid out for comparison, including pills, a ring, an IUD and condoms

Birth control lets you choose if and when to get pregnant. In the US, you can pick from more than a dozen FDA-approved methods, from a rod in your arm that lasts years to condoms you buy at any drugstore. This guide compares every major option side by side, with effectiveness rates, side effects, typical US costs and tips for choosing.

What is the most effective birth control?

The implant, hormonal IUDs, the copper IUD and sterilization (tubal procedures or vasectomy) are the most effective forms of birth control. With typical use, fewer than 1 in 100 people using them become pregnant in a year.

They work so well because there is nothing to remember once they are in place. Daily or every-time methods work well too, but real-life slip-ups lower their numbers.

Effectiveness is only one factor. Cost, side effects, STI protection and future pregnancy plans matter too. The best method is one you can use consistently.

Birth control effectiveness chart

The table below compares common methods sold or prescribed in the US. "Typical use" reflects how people actually use a method, including mistakes. "Perfect use" assumes it is used exactly as directed every time. Figures are approximate numbers of users out of 100 who become pregnant in the first year, based on CDC and FDA summaries.

MethodPregnancies per 100 users in 1 year (typical use)Perfect useHow often you actProtects against STIs?
Implant (arm rod)About 0.1About 0.1Lasts up to 3 years (label)No
Hormonal IUDAbout 0.1-0.4About 0.1-0.4Lasts 3-8 years, by brandNo
Copper IUDAbout 0.8About 0.6Lasts up to 10 yearsNo
VasectomyAbout 0.15About 0.1Once (permanent)No
Tubal sterilizationAbout 0.5About 0.5Once (permanent)No
Shot (injection)About 4Less than 1Every 3 monthsNo
Pill (combined or progestin-only)About 7Less than 1Every dayNo
PatchAbout 7Less than 1WeeklyNo
Vaginal ringAbout 7Less than 1Monthly (or yearly ring)No
External (male) condomAbout 13About 2Every timeYes
Diaphragm with spermicideAbout 17About 6Every timeNo
WithdrawalAbout 20About 4Every timeNo
Internal (female) condomAbout 21About 5Every timeYes
Spermicide aloneAbout 21About 16Every timeNo
Fertility awareness methodsAbout 2-23Varies by methodDaily trackingNo

The CDC publishes similar figures. For comparison, about 85 out of 100 sexually active people using no method become pregnant within a year. Using two methods together, such as condoms plus the pill, lowers the overall chance of pregnancy and adds STI protection.

How do contraceptive methods work?

Every method keeps sperm and egg from meeting in one of a few ways.

  • Stopping ovulation: Estrogen and progestin in the pill, patch and ring, and the progestin in the shot and implant, keep the ovaries from releasing an egg.
  • Thickening cervical mucus: Progestins make mucus at the cervix thick and sticky, so sperm have trouble getting through. This is the main action of hormonal IUDs and some progestin-only pills.
  • Blocking sperm: Condoms, diaphragms and cervical caps form a physical barrier. Spermicide damages sperm.
  • Making the uterus unfriendly to sperm: Copper ions released by the copper IUD are toxic to sperm and eggs.
  • Closing the pathway: Vasectomy and tubal sterilization permanently block the tubes sperm or eggs travel through.

None of these methods ends an existing pregnancy. Emergency contraception also works before pregnancy begins, mainly by delaying ovulation.

Long-acting methods: IUDs and the implant

IUDs and the implant are called long-acting reversible contraception (LARC). They last for years, are over 99% effective as birth control, and fertility usually returns quickly after removal. Major medical groups such as ACOG consider them first-line options for most people, including teens and people who have never given birth.

Hormonal IUD

An IUD is a small T-shaped device placed in the uterus during an office visit that takes a few minutes. Hormonal IUDs release a low dose of a progestin called levonorgestrel. They often make periods lighter, and some users stop having periods altogether, which is safe. Depending on the brand, they last 3 to 8 years.

Copper IUD

The copper IUD has no hormones and lasts up to 10 years. It is a good pick if you want to avoid hormones or cannot use them. The tradeoff is that periods can get heavier or crampier, especially in the first 3 to 6 months.

Implant

The implant is a thin, flexible rod about the size of a matchstick placed under the skin of the upper arm with a numbing shot. It releases etonogestrel, a progestin. Irregular or unpredictable bleeding is its most common side effect, and it is the single most effective reversible method available.

Placement can cause cramping (IUD) or bruising (implant) for a day or two. Removal is a quick office visit.

Hormonal methods: pill, patch, ring and shot

Short-acting hormonal birth control methods are about 93% effective with typical use (96% for the shot) and over 99% with perfect use. They work mainly by stopping ovulation and thickening cervical mucus.

  • Pill: Taken once a day. Combined pills contain estrogen and progestin; progestin-only pills contain progestin alone.
  • Patch: Worn on the skin and changed weekly for three weeks, followed by a patch-free week. It contains estrogen and progestin.
  • Ring: A soft, flexible ring placed in the vagina. Depending on the product, it stays in for three weeks and is then replaced, or one ring is reused for a full year.
  • Shot: An injection of medroxyprogesterone given every 3 months by a clinician (or self-injected with one version). Long-term use can lower bone density, and fertility can take up to a year or more to return after stopping.

Many people like these methods for their extra benefits. Combined hormonal birth control often makes periods lighter, more regular and less painful, can improve acne and symptoms of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), and lowers the long-term risk of ovarian and endometrial cancer. Hormonal IUDs are also a common treatment for heavy periods.

Methods containing estrogen are not recommended for some people, such as smokers over 35 or people with a history of blood clots, migraine with aura, stroke or some heart conditions. A clinician can check which options are safe for you.

Non-hormonal options

If you want to avoid hormones, you still have good birth control choices. The copper IUD is the most effective non-hormonal method. Others include barrier methods, a prescription vaginal gel, fertility awareness and vasectomy.

Condoms and other barrier methods

Barrier methods physically block sperm from reaching an egg. External and internal condoms are the only birth control methods that also lower the risk of STIs, including HIV. External condoms are about 87% effective with typical use and 98% with perfect use. They are cheap, sold without a prescription and come in latex and non-latex materials.

Diaphragms and cervical caps are reusable silicone cups used with spermicide and need a prescription. Spermicide, a prescription pH-lowering gel and the sponge are less effective on their own.

As one example of global supply, HLL Lifecare in India manufactures condoms, Copper-T IUDs and oral contraceptive pills for public health programs. In the US, look for condoms and devices cleared or approved by the FDA.

Fertility awareness and natural methods

Fertility awareness methods (FAMs) involve tracking your cycle and avoiding sex or using a barrier on fertile days. They range from about 77% to 98% effective with typical use, depending on the method and how carefully it is followed.

Common approaches track basal body temperature, cervical mucus or calendar days; combining signs works better. FAMs need regular cycles, daily attention and partner cooperation.

Withdrawal ("pulling out") is about 80% effective with typical use.

Permanent methods: tubal sterilization and vasectomy

Sterilization is permanent birth control and is over 99% effective. It suits adults who are sure they do not want future pregnancies.

Tubal sterilization closes, cuts or removes the fallopian tubes. Removing the tubes completely (salpingectomy) may also lower the risk of ovarian cancer.

A vasectomy blocks the tubes that carry sperm. It is a quick outpatient procedure done under local anesthesia, with a shorter recovery and lower cost than tubal surgery. It is not effective right away: use another method until a follow-up semen test, usually about 3 months later, confirms there are no sperm.

Reversal is costly and not always successful. Federal rules require a 30-day waiting period for sterilization paid for by Medicaid.

Emergency contraception: what if my method fails?

Emergency contraception (EC) can lower the chance of pregnancy after unprotected sex or a method failure, such as a broken condom or missed pills. It works best the sooner it is used.

  1. Levonorgestrel pill: Sold over the counter with no age limit or ID, labeled for use within 72 hours. Typical US price is about $10-$50.
  2. Ulipristal acetate pill: Needs a prescription and works up to 5 days after sex. It may work better than levonorgestrel for people with a higher body weight.
  3. Copper IUD: Placed within 5 days, it is the most effective form of EC and keeps working as ongoing birth control for years.

EC does not end or harm an existing pregnancy and is not meant to replace regular birth control.

Is contraception safe? Side effects and risks

Yes, modern birth control is safe for most people, and serious problems are rare. Pregnancy itself carries higher health risks than any modern method. Most side effects are mild and often fade within the first 2 to 3 months.

  • Common with hormonal methods: spotting between periods, nausea, breast tenderness, headaches and mood changes.
  • Common with the copper IUD: heavier periods and more cramping.
  • Weight: Most research has not found that the pill, patch, ring, IUDs or implant cause significant weight gain. The shot is the method most linked to weight gain.
  • Rare but serious: blood clots with estrogen-containing methods, and, with IUDs, a small chance of the device moving out of place or, very rarely, puncturing the uterus.

To guide clinicians, the CDC publishes medical eligibility criteria that rate each method's safety for people with specific conditions, such as high blood pressure, diabetes or a history of breast cancer. If a side effect bothers you after three months, switching to a different method or dose often helps.

Common myths

  • "You need to take a break from the pill." There is no medical reason for regular breaks, and stopping raises the chance of an unplanned pregnancy.
  • "Birth control causes infertility." Fertility returns after you stop reversible methods. Only the shot can cause a delay of several months.
  • "Hormonal methods cause cancer." Combined methods may slightly raise breast and cervical cancer risk while in use, but they lower ovarian, endometrial and colorectal cancer risk.

Where to get birth control in the US

  • Over the counter: Condoms, spermicide, the sponge, one progestin-only daily pill and levonorgestrel emergency pills are sold in pharmacies, grocery stores and online with no prescription or age limit.
  • Pharmacist prescribing: In many states, a pharmacist can prescribe the pill, patch, ring or shot after a short health questionnaire and blood pressure check.
  • Telehealth: Online services can prescribe the pill, patch or ring after a video visit or questionnaire and mail refills to you.
  • Doctor or clinic visit: IUDs, the implant, diaphragms and sterilization need an in-person visit with a doctor, nurse practitioner or other trained clinician.
  • Low-cost clinics: Title X family planning clinics, community health centers and many local health departments offer confidential care on a sliding fee scale.

Ask for a 12-month supply of pills, patches or rings if your plan allows it.

How much does birth control cost in the US?

Under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), as US government guidance explains, most private health plans must cover at least one form of each FDA-approved birth control method for women with no copay when you use an in-network provider. Some employers with religious objections are exempt. Medicaid also covers family planning services in every state.

MethodTypical US cost without insuranceHow long it lasts
IUD or implantAbout $0-$1,300 including placement3-10 years
ShotAbout $50-$150 per injection3 months
Pill, patch or ringAbout $0-$200 per month1 month
OTC progestin-only pillAbout $15-$25 per month1 month
CondomsAbout $0.50-$2 each (often free at clinics)One use
VasectomyAbout $0-$1,000+Permanent
Tubal sterilizationAbout $0-$6,000Permanent

These birth control prices are typical US estimates and vary by state, clinic and brand. Federally funded Title X clinics, overseen by the Office of Population Affairs, provide low- or no-cost services based on income. Community health centers often use a sliding fee scale.

Federal ACA rules do not require plans to cover vasectomy, though some states do. Call your insurer to confirm what is covered before you book.

How do I choose the right birth control?

Start by asking what matters most to you: top effectiveness, no hormones, lighter periods, STI protection, or something you only think about once every few years. Then review your health history with a clinician or pharmacist.

  • "I don't want to think about it": implant or IUD.
  • "I want no hormones": copper IUD, condoms, diaphragm or fertility awareness.
  • "I want lighter or fewer periods": hormonal IUD, or a combined pill, patch or ring used continuously.
  • "I need STI protection": condoms, alone or with another method.
  • "I'm breastfeeding": progestin-only methods, IUDs, the implant or condoms.
  • "I want to get pregnant within a year": a method you can stop anytime, such as the pill, ring or condoms. Avoid the shot.
  • "I'm done having kids": vasectomy, tubal sterilization or a long-acting method.

The FDA lists every approved option. If you think your method may have failed, a home pregnancy test is most accurate from the first day of a missed period.

Starting, switching and missed doses

Most methods can be started on any day of your cycle once a clinician is reasonably sure you are not pregnant. This is called a "quick start." Whether you need backup depends on the method and timing.

MethodBackup needed if started mid-cycle
Copper IUDNone; works right away
Hormonal IUD or implant7 days (none if started in the first days of your period)
Combined pill, patch or ring7 days (none if started within 5 days of your period starting)
Progestin-only pill2 days
Shot7 days (none if given within 7 days of your period starting)

What to do if you miss a dose

  • Combined pill: Take the missed pill as soon as you remember, even if that means two in one day. If you missed two or more in a row, use condoms for 7 days and consider emergency contraception if you had sex recently.
  • Progestin-only pill: If you are more than 3 hours late with most brands, take it now and use backup for 2 days.
  • Patch or ring: If it falls off or out for more than 48 hours, put a new one on or in and use backup for 7 days.
  • Shot: You can usually get it up to 2 weeks late without backup. Later than that, you may need a pregnancy test and backup for 7 days.

Medicines that can lower effectiveness

Most antibiotics do not make birth control fail. The main exception is rifampin, a tuberculosis drug. Some seizure medicines, certain HIV drugs and the supplement St. John's wort can also weaken the pill, patch, ring and implant. Tell every prescriber which method you use, and ask a pharmacist before starting a new medicine.

When to see a doctor

Get medical care right away if you notice any of these warning signs while using birth control:

  • Sudden leg pain or swelling, chest pain, shortness of breath, severe headache or vision changes while on a hormonal method (call 911 for chest pain or trouble breathing).
  • Severe pelvic pain, fever or unusual discharge after an IUD placement.
  • You cannot feel your IUD strings, or you feel the hard plastic of the device.
  • Severe belly pain or a positive pregnancy test with an IUD or implant, which can signal an ectopic pregnancy.
  • Side effects such as heavy bleeding, depression or mood changes that last beyond the first few months.

Also book a visit if you want to switch methods, plan a pregnancy or start a new medicine.

Key takeaways

  • The implant, IUDs and sterilization are the most effective birth control, at over 99%.
  • The pill, patch and ring are about 93% effective with typical use; the shot is about 96%.
  • Only condoms protect against STIs, so pair them with another method if STIs are a concern.
  • Most private plans must cover birth control with no copay under the ACA, and Title X clinics offer low-cost care.
  • The best method is the one you will use consistently. You can always switch.

Frequently asked questions

What is the safest form of birth control?

Condoms and the copper IUD have very few medical restrictions, and most people can safely use most methods. The safest choice for you depends on your health history, such as blood pressure, smoking, migraines or clotting problems, so review your options with a clinician or pharmacist.

Which birth control does not cause weight gain?

Most studies have not found that the pill, patch, ring, IUDs or implant cause significant weight gain. The shot is the method most linked to weight gain in some users. Non-hormonal options such as the copper IUD and condoms have no effect on weight.

What is the cheapest birth control?

With most private insurance or Medicaid, many methods cost nothing. Without coverage, condoms and generic pills are the cheapest up front. Over several years, an IUD or implant often costs the least per month, and Title X clinics charge based on income.

Can you still get pregnant on birth control?

Yes, though it is uncommon with correct use. Pregnancy is most likely with methods that depend on daily or every-time use, such as the pill or condoms. If you have pregnancy symptoms or a missed period while on any method, take a home pregnancy test.

Does birth control affect future fertility?

For most methods, fertility returns soon after stopping, often within a month or two. The shot can delay the return of fertility for several months to a year. Sterilization is meant to be permanent, and reversal is costly and not always successful.

Can teens get birth control without parental consent?

In many states, teens can consent to birth control on their own, and Title X clinics offer confidential care regardless of age. Rules vary by state and can change. Condoms and levonorgestrel emergency pills can be bought over the counter at any age.

Does birth control stop your period?

Some methods can. Hormonal IUDs, the implant, the shot and continuous use of combined pills, patches or rings often make periods lighter or stop them. Having no period on these methods is generally safe and does not mean you are less fertile later.

Is it safe to use birth control for many years?

Yes, for most healthy people, long-term use is safe, and you do not need breaks. The shot is the main exception because of its effect on bone density. Review your method with a clinician every year or when your health changes.

Can you use two birth control methods at once?

Yes. Combining methods, such as condoms with the pill or an IUD, lowers the chance of pregnancy and adds STI protection. Avoid using an external and internal condom together, because friction between them can cause tearing or slipping.

Does birth control cause depression?

Most people do not have mood changes on birth control, but some notice low mood, especially with hormonal methods. If you feel depressed or anxious after starting a method, talk to a clinician. Switching to a different hormone, dose or a non-hormonal option often helps.

HLL

About this guide

Written by the HLL Health editorial team using guidance from US health authorities such as the FDA, CDC and NIH. HLL Lifecare has made contraceptives and medical products since 1966. This guide is general information, not medical advice.